top of page

52332993_816215032055872_162501966692352

- Since 2015 -

PRIORITY BAKING CO.

HOMEMADE BAKED GOODS

ABOUT OUR BAKERY

FRESH HOMEMADE GOODIES

I enjoy the whole process, including the creativity of tweaking an old recipe or the challenge of learning a new one. I love trying new things and creating beautiful, delicious treats that bring smiles to people's faces.

52332993_816215032055872_162501966692352

CONTACT US

Easter Specials

(Last Order Date March 26th, 2026) Orders will be ready for pickup Week of April 1st 2026

Easter Eggs:

Fillings: Peanut Butter, Buttercream, Coconut, Orange Buttercream, Raspberry Buttercream

Coatings: Milk Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, White Chocolate

Our order deadline for homemade XL Easter 🐣 eggs is tomorrow, Thursday, March 26th. If you haven’t ordered yet, reach out today to make sure you do to ensure your order will be ready for pickup/delivery by April 1st.
You can order direct through our website at:

https://www.prioritybakingcompany.com/product-page/easter-chocolate-eggs

Or comment here, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716.

Our order deadline for homemade XL Easter 🐣 eggs is tomorrow, Thursday, March 26th. If you haven’t ordered yet, reach out today to make sure you do to ensure your order will be ready for pickup/delivery by April 1st.
You can order direct through our website at:

https://www.prioritybakingcompany.com/product-page/easter-chocolate-eggs

Or comment here, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716.

It’s that time of the year again; crisp fall mornings, leaves 🍁 falling, and our ovens working double time to produce pumpkin 🎃 rolls, pies 🥧, and other tasty Thanksgiving treats!

We are now taking pre-orders for our Thanksgiving specials until Friday Nov 21st. All orders will be ready for pickup/local delivery on Tuesday Nov 25th.

As always comment below ⬇️, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order today!

We are offering the following specials again this year:

-XL Pumpkin Rolls (serves 10-12) and are $20 each or 2 for $30
-Mini Pie Flights (6 mini hand pies: pumpkin, apple, cherry, pecan, chocolate chess, and molasses coconut) for $12
-9” pies for $20 each: pumpkin, chocolate chess, homestyle apple crumb, or homestyle cherry crumb
-Pumpkin Spice Cake Pops (our pumpkin roll flavor coated in white chocolate) 1/2 dozen for $15 or 1 dozen for $25

Don’t hesitate to reach out and place your order today! Thanksgiving will be here before we know it!

It’s that time of the year again; crisp fall mornings, leaves 🍁 falling, and our ovens working double time to produce pumpkin 🎃 rolls, pies 🥧, and other tasty Thanksgiving treats!

We are now taking pre-orders for our Thanksgiving specials until Friday Nov 21st. All orders will be ready for pickup/local delivery on Tuesday Nov 25th.

As always comment below ⬇️, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order today!

We are offering the following specials again this year:

-XL Pumpkin Rolls (serves 10-12) and are $20 each or 2 for $30
-Mini Pie Flights (6 mini hand pies: pumpkin, apple, cherry, pecan, chocolate chess, and molasses coconut) for $12
-9” pies for $20 each: pumpkin, chocolate chess, homestyle apple crumb, or homestyle cherry crumb
-Pumpkin Spice Cake Pops (our pumpkin roll flavor coated in white chocolate) 1/2 dozen for $15 or 1 dozen for $25

Don’t hesitate to reach out and place your order today! Thanksgiving will be here before we know it!

Some of our recent fall bakes lately: pumpkin 🎃 spice cupcakes 🧁, our new caramel crunch popcorn, apple 🍎 butter cookies 🍪, and our apple cider cupcakes 🧁. Hit us up to place an order for yours today, or keep your eyes peeled for other pop up events happening in the future!

Some of our recent fall bakes lately: pumpkin 🎃 spice cupcakes 🧁, our new caramel crunch popcorn, apple 🍎 butter cookies 🍪, and our apple cider cupcakes 🧁. Hit us up to place an order for yours today, or keep your eyes peeled for other pop up events happening in the future!

So happy to help support two great causes recently with these cupcakes for the “Hearts for Quinn” event this past weekend which also helped raise money for the Stronger Hearts Foundation. Their event was a big success and we were very honored to help sponsor it as well as provide some sweet treats.
#strongerheartsfoundation #heartsforquinn

So happy to help support two great causes recently with these cupcakes for the “Hearts for Quinn” event this past weekend which also helped raise money for the Stronger Hearts Foundation. Their event was a big success and we were very honored to help sponsor it as well as provide some sweet treats.
#strongerheartsfoundation #heartsforquinn

Come out to Cow-Lick Clips and Clips grand opening!

Come out to Cow-Lick Clips and Clips grand opening!

Come join us at the grand opening of @Cow-Lick Clips & Cuts!! We are excited to be here to welcome you to our community!!

Congratulations on your business and we are excited to watch your business flourish!

#GrandOpening #shippensburgpa #prioritybakingcompany #bakedgoods
#CowLickClipsandCuts

Chamber of Commerce-Shippensburg Area #cowlickclipsandcuts

Come join us at the grand opening of @Cow-Lick Clips & Cuts!! We are excited to be here to welcome you to our community!!

Congratulations on your business and we are excited to watch your business flourish!

#GrandOpening #shippensburgpa #prioritybakingcompany #bakedgoods
#CowLickClipsandCuts

Chamber of Commerce-Shippensburg Area #cowlickclipsandcuts

Come check out our stand tomorrow, Sept 27th from 9a-2pm at Cow-Lick Clips and Cuts at 24 W. King Street, Shippensburg, PA 17257 during their grand opening event! We will have all the fall inspired bakes including these and more. Check us out while supplies last and come support a new local business!

Come check out our stand tomorrow, Sept 27th from 9a-2pm at Cow-Lick Clips and Cuts at 24 W. King Street, Shippensburg, PA 17257 during their grand opening event! We will have all the fall inspired bakes including these and more. Check us out while supplies last and come support a new local business!

🐾🐶 Fresh from the oven for our furry friends! 🦴✨

Just whipped up a batch of homemade dog treats for a special order, and they smell soooo good even the humans are jealous 😋💕 Made with love (and tail wags in mind), these treats are the perfect way to spoil your pup! 🐕💛

Because every good dog deserves something delicious. 🐾🐾

#HomemadeDogTreats #PawfectSnacks #HappyPups #DogLoversOfInstagram #BakingForDogs #FurryFriends #TreatYourPup #prioritybakingcompany

🐾🐶 Fresh from the oven for our furry friends! 🦴✨

Just whipped up a batch of homemade dog treats for a special order, and they smell soooo good even the humans are jealous 😋💕 Made with love (and tail wags in mind), these treats are the perfect way to spoil your pup! 🐕💛

Because every good dog deserves something delicious. 🐾🐾

#HomemadeDogTreats #PawfectSnacks #HappyPups #DogLoversOfInstagram #BakingForDogs #FurryFriends #TreatYourPup #prioritybakingcompany

🇺🇸✨ Happy Labor Day from our kitchen to yours! 🍪🍫🎉

Today we’re celebrating all the hardworking hands that make life a little sweeter—whether you’re baking, building, teaching, serving, or creating, your work matters. 💪❤️

We’re grateful for the chance to do what we love—baking joy into every batch! 🥳 Wishing you a day full of rest, family, and of course… treats! 🍰🌈

#HappyLaborDay #LaborDayWeekend #BakersOfInstagram #SweetCelebrations #MadeWithLove #WorkHardBakeHard #prioritybakingcompany

🇺🇸✨ Happy Labor Day from our kitchen to yours! 🍪🍫🎉

Today we’re celebrating all the hardworking hands that make life a little sweeter—whether you’re baking, building, teaching, serving, or creating, your work matters. 💪❤️

We’re grateful for the chance to do what we love—baking joy into every batch! 🥳 Wishing you a day full of rest, family, and of course… treats! 🍰🌈

#HappyLaborDay #LaborDayWeekend #BakersOfInstagram #SweetCelebrations #MadeWithLove #WorkHardBakeHard #prioritybakingcompany

✨🍪 Fresh Out of the Oven! 🍫🎉

Just finished baking a batch of Funfetti Cookie Brownies for a special order—and wow 🤩 they’re gooey, chewy, and bursting with sprinkles! 🌈💕

Nothing says happiness like the perfect mix of brownies + cookies + confetti magic. 🥳 Who else needs one (or five)? 🙋‍♀️🙋‍♂️

#FreshBakes #FunfettiMagic #CookieBrownies #BakersOfInstagram #DessertGoals #SweetToothSatisfied #HomemadeWithLove #BrownieBliss #SprinkleJoy #prioritybakingcompany

✨🍪 Fresh Out of the Oven! 🍫🎉

Just finished baking a batch of Funfetti Cookie Brownies for a special order—and wow 🤩 they’re gooey, chewy, and bursting with sprinkles! 🌈💕

Nothing says happiness like the perfect mix of brownies + cookies + confetti magic. 🥳 Who else needs one (or five)? 🙋‍♀️🙋‍♂️

#FreshBakes #FunfettiMagic #CookieBrownies #BakersOfInstagram #DessertGoals #SweetToothSatisfied #HomemadeWithLove #BrownieBliss #SprinkleJoy #prioritybakingcompany

Thanks to a huge response a large amount of our extra eggs have been claimed, but we do still have the following available:

Dark PB: 4 dozen
Dark Maple BC: 4
Milk Orange BC: 10
Dark Orange BC: 9
Milk Raspberry BC: 10
Dark Raspberry BC: 3

Extras are available first come, first served. As always, comment below, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order.

Eggs are $2.00 each, $10.00 per 1/2 dozen, and $20.00 per dozen with ability to mix and match flavors and coatings.

Big thanks to everyone who has reached out already to order!

Thanks to a huge response a large amount of our extra eggs have been claimed, but we do still have the following available:

Dark PB: 4 dozen
Dark Maple BC: 4
Milk Orange BC: 10
Dark Orange BC: 9
Milk Raspberry BC: 10
Dark Raspberry BC: 3

Extras are available first come, first served. As always, comment below, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order.

Eggs are $2.00 each, $10.00 per 1/2 dozen, and $20.00 per dozen with ability to mix and match flavors and coatings.

Big thanks to everyone who has reached out already to order!

For anyone that missed the cutoff for ordering our homemade chocolate Easter eggs, you are in luck!

We have the following extras available to order on a first come, first served basis. Easter is a week away so it’s a great time to snag some last minute goodies before the big day!

Milk PB: 7 dozen
Dark PB: 6 dozen

And the following flavors in the individual amounts listed:
Milk coconut: 6
Dark coconut: 5
Milk Maple BC: 4
Dark Maple BC: 4
Milk Orange BC: 10
Dark Orange BC: 9
Milk Raspberry BC: 10
Dark Raspberry: 6
Milk Peppermint: 7
Dark Peppermint: 5

Eggs are $2.00 each, 1/2 dozen for $10.00, and a dozen for $20.00.

Feel free to comment below, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to claim your order today!

For anyone that missed the cutoff for ordering our homemade chocolate Easter eggs, you are in luck!

We have the following extras available to order on a first come, first served basis. Easter is a week away so it’s a great time to snag some last minute goodies before the big day!

Milk PB: 7 dozen
Dark PB: 6 dozen

And the following flavors in the individual amounts listed:
Milk coconut: 6
Dark coconut: 5
Milk Maple BC: 4
Dark Maple BC: 4
Milk Orange BC: 10
Dark Orange BC: 9
Milk Raspberry BC: 10
Dark Raspberry: 6
Milk Peppermint: 7
Dark Peppermint: 5

Eggs are $2.00 each, 1/2 dozen for $10.00, and a dozen for $20.00.

Feel free to comment below, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to claim your order today!

Today is the last day to get your homemade chocolate egg orders in to be on time for the cutoff of Friday the 11th. All orders will be ready for pickup/ local delivery to the Shippensburg area on Weds April 16th. As always, DM us here, comment below, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, order direct through our website at https://www.prioritybakingcompany.com/product-page/easter-chocolate-eggs or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order before April 11th.

Eggs are $2.00 each, or you can order a 1/2 dozen (6 eggs) for $10.00 or 1 dozen (12 eggs) for $20.00.

Our flavor options are as follows:

- *Most Popular* are our Peanut Butter eggs in milk, dark, or white chocolate coatings.

- Spicy PB eggs (our classic peanut butter filling kicked up a notch with cayenne and chili notes for a sweet heat option) in either milk, dark, or white chocolate coatings.

- Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Coconut eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Maple Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Orange Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- *New Flavor* is Raspberry Buttercream in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Peppermint Patties in milk or dark chocolate coating.

Today is the last day to get your homemade chocolate egg orders in to be on time for the cutoff of Friday the 11th. All orders will be ready for pickup/ local delivery to the Shippensburg area on Weds April 16th. As always, DM us here, comment below, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, order direct through our website at https://www.prioritybakingcompany.com/product-page/easter-chocolate-eggs or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order before April 11th.

Eggs are $2.00 each, or you can order a 1/2 dozen (6 eggs) for $10.00 or 1 dozen (12 eggs) for $20.00.

Our flavor options are as follows:

- *Most Popular* are our Peanut Butter eggs in milk, dark, or white chocolate coatings.

- Spicy PB eggs (our classic peanut butter filling kicked up a notch with cayenne and chili notes for a sweet heat option) in either milk, dark, or white chocolate coatings.

- Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Coconut eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Maple Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Orange Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- *New Flavor* is Raspberry Buttercream in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Peppermint Patties in milk or dark chocolate coating.

✨Attention✨

There is just under a week left to get your orders in for our homemade chocolate Easter eggs!

We are taking orders from now until Friday, April 11th, 2025. All orders will be ready for pickup/local delivery in Shippensburg, PA starting Wednesday, April 16th, 2025.
Feel free to comment below, DM us here, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, order directly through our website at https://www.prioritybakingcompany.com/product-page/easter-chocolate-eggs or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order before April 11th.

Eggs are $2.00 each, or you can order a 1/2 dozen (6 eggs) for $10.00 or 1 dozen (12 eggs) for $20.00.

Our flavor options are as follows:

- *Most Popular* are our Peanut Butter eggs in milk, dark, or white chocolate coatings.

- Spicy PB eggs (our classic peanut butter filling kicked up a notch with cayenne and chili notes for a sweet heat option) in either milk, dark, or white chocolate coatings.

- Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Coconut eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Maple Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Orange Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- *New Flavor* is Raspberry Buttercream in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Peppermint Patties in milk or dark chocolate coating.

Don't miss out on making your Easter extra sweet this year with Priority Baking Company. Order now and hop into a world of flavor!

✨Attention✨

There is just under a week left to get your orders in for our homemade chocolate Easter eggs!

We are taking orders from now until Friday, April 11th, 2025. All orders will be ready for pickup/local delivery in Shippensburg, PA starting Wednesday, April 16th, 2025.
Feel free to comment below, DM us here, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, order directly through our website at https://www.prioritybakingcompany.com/product-page/easter-chocolate-eggs or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order before April 11th.

Eggs are $2.00 each, or you can order a 1/2 dozen (6 eggs) for $10.00 or 1 dozen (12 eggs) for $20.00.

Our flavor options are as follows:

- *Most Popular* are our Peanut Butter eggs in milk, dark, or white chocolate coatings.

- Spicy PB eggs (our classic peanut butter filling kicked up a notch with cayenne and chili notes for a sweet heat option) in either milk, dark, or white chocolate coatings.

- Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Coconut eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Maple Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Orange Buttercream eggs in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- *New Flavor* is Raspberry Buttercream in milk or dark chocolate coating.

- Peppermint Patties in milk or dark chocolate coating.

Don't miss out on making your Easter extra sweet this year with Priority Baking Company. Order now and hop into a world of flavor!

Feeling festive 🎄with this cookie platter we put together for an early Christmas gathering this weekend. Looking for a larger option to satisfy your sweet tooth this holiday season? Our large cookie platters hold 8 dozen cookies in up to 8 flavors of your choice! Order yours today on our website at prioritybakingcompany.com

Feeling festive 🎄with this cookie platter we put together for an early Christmas gathering this weekend. Looking for a larger option to satisfy your sweet tooth this holiday season? Our large cookie platters hold 8 dozen cookies in up to 8 flavors of your choice! Order yours today on our website at prioritybakingcompany.com

Still trying to decide what to do for Thanksgiving? Let us take care of dessert for you! We are still taking orders for our Thanksgiving specials until this Friday, November 22nd. All orders will be ready for pickup (in Shippensburg, PA) or delivery on Tuesday, November 26th. As always, comment below, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or order directly through our website at:

https://www.prioritybakingcompany.com/thanksgiving-specials

We have the following specials:

🎃 XL Pumpkin Rolls $20.00 each or 2 for $30.00

🥧 Pies (9” size) for $20.00 each in Pumpkin, Chocolate Chess, Apple Crumb, or Cherry Crumb

🌟New Mini Pie Flights 🌟 6 mini hand pies for $12.00 including one of each of the following flavors: Pumpkin, Chocolate Chess, Pecan, Apple Crumb, Cherry Crumb, and Molasses Coconut 🥥

💕 Pumpkin Spice Cake Pops $15.00 for a 1/2 dozen, $25.00 for 1 dozen

Still trying to decide what to do for Thanksgiving? Let us take care of dessert for you! We are still taking orders for our Thanksgiving specials until this Friday, November 22nd. All orders will be ready for pickup (in Shippensburg, PA) or delivery on Tuesday, November 26th. As always, comment below, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or order directly through our website at:

https://www.prioritybakingcompany.com/thanksgiving-specials

We have the following specials:

🎃 XL Pumpkin Rolls $20.00 each or 2 for $30.00

🥧 Pies (9” size) for $20.00 each in Pumpkin, Chocolate Chess, Apple Crumb, or Cherry Crumb

🌟New Mini Pie Flights 🌟 6 mini hand pies for $12.00 including one of each of the following flavors: Pumpkin, Chocolate Chess, Pecan, Apple Crumb, Cherry Crumb, and Molasses Coconut 🥥

💕 Pumpkin Spice Cake Pops $15.00 for a 1/2 dozen, $25.00 for 1 dozen

We know we’ve been quiet for awhile and that’s because we were prepping our 2024 Thanksgiving specials!

Orders are due by Friday, Nov 22nd and will be ready for pickup/local delivery on Tuesday, Nov 26th.

As always, feel free to comment below, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order today!

Specials include:

XL Pumpkin Rolls, $20.00 each or 2 for $30.00

*New* Mini Pie Flights: 6 Mini Hand Pies for $12.00, including 1 each of the following flavors:
Pumpkin, Apple Crumb, Cherry Crumb, Chocolate Chess, Pecan, and Molasses Coconut

Traditional 9” Pies for $20.00 each in the following flavors: Pumpkin, Chocolate Chess, Apple Crumb, and Cherry Crumb

Pumpkin Spice Cake Pops $15.00 for 1/2 dozen and $25.00 for 1 dozen

We know we’ve been quiet for awhile and that’s because we were prepping our 2024 Thanksgiving specials!

Orders are due by Friday, Nov 22nd and will be ready for pickup/local delivery on Tuesday, Nov 26th.

As always, feel free to comment below, DM us, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order today!

Specials include:

XL Pumpkin Rolls, $20.00 each or 2 for $30.00

*New* Mini Pie Flights: 6 Mini Hand Pies for $12.00, including 1 each of the following flavors:
Pumpkin, Apple Crumb, Cherry Crumb, Chocolate Chess, Pecan, and Molasses Coconut

Traditional 9” Pies for $20.00 each in the following flavors: Pumpkin, Chocolate Chess, Apple Crumb, and Cherry Crumb

Pumpkin Spice Cake Pops $15.00 for 1/2 dozen and $25.00 for 1 dozen

Today’s the last day to get your orders in for your fall bakes! Orders will be ready for pickup/local delivery on Friday, Oct 4th.
Can’t decide what to order? Make it easy and grab our baker’s fall 🍁🍂 assortment box.
It has a little of everything for $40.00.

As always, dm us here, comment below, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to get your order in by the end of the day today.

Baker’s Fall Assortment Box $40.00
6 cupcakes (2 of each flavor)
1 dozen assorted cookies (3 of each flavor)
2 cookie sandwiches
4 doughnuts
1/4lb of fudge

Today’s the last day to get your orders in for your fall bakes! Orders will be ready for pickup/local delivery on Friday, Oct 4th.
Can’t decide what to order? Make it easy and grab our baker’s fall 🍁🍂 assortment box.
It has a little of everything for $40.00.

As always, dm us here, comment below, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to get your order in by the end of the day today.

Baker’s Fall Assortment Box $40.00
6 cupcakes (2 of each flavor)
1 dozen assorted cookies (3 of each flavor)
2 cookie sandwiches
4 doughnuts
1/4lb of fudge

Another of the celebrations we helped to make just that little bit sweeter in the month of September! Congratulations to Davey and Heather on their wedding, may you have many years of wedded bliss. Their classic cupcake choices and cake went perfectly with the fall theme and beautiful venue.

Another of the celebrations we helped to make just that little bit sweeter in the month of September! Congratulations to Davey and Heather on their wedding, may you have many years of wedded bliss. Their classic cupcake choices and cake went perfectly with the fall theme and beautiful venue.

Another of the celebrations we catered last week, a dessert bar for a baby shower! Congrats to the parents to be and thanks to Lisa for sharing her video to show how she displayed everything for the event!
We love doing dessert bars to make your event that much more special and sweet! Don’t hesitate to reach out to order yours for your next event.

Another of the celebrations we catered last week, a dessert bar for a baby shower! Congrats to the parents to be and thanks to Lisa for sharing her video to show how she displayed everything for the event!
We love doing dessert bars to make your event that much more special and sweet! Don’t hesitate to reach out to order yours for your next event.

It’s officially Fall, so you know what that means…Fall 🍁🍂 Bakes:
Caramel Apple 🍏 Cookie Sandwiches:
Two large chewy apple oat cookies with a brown sugar buttercream and salted caramel drizzle sandwiched in the middle

$15.00 for a 1/2 dozen and $25.00 for a dozen

Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes 🧁:
Need we say more? Moist, fluffy pumpkin spice cake topped with cream cheese frosting or vanilla buttercream and topped with freshly grated nutmeg

$15.00 for a 1/2 dozen and $25.00 for a dozen.

Apple Pie Cupcakes 🧁:
Brown sugar butter cake with apple pie filling topped with a cinnamon cream cheese frosting.

$15.00 for a 1/2 dozen and $25.00 for a
dozen

S’mores Cupcakes:
Crushed graham cracker base, chocolate cake, topped with a graham cracker cream cheese frosting and all the s’mores fixings

$15.00 for 1/2 dozen and $25.00 for a dozen

White Chocolate Chip Pumpkin Snickerdoodles(Egg Free):
$15.00 per dozen

Molasses Cookies:
$15.00 per dozen

Apple Butter Cookies:
A moist Apple flavored brown sugar cookie, slightly chewy and rolled in sugar
$15.00 per dozen

Butterbeer Cookies:
Just like the Harry Potter beverage of choice, these have a great flavor and are a fall classic
$15.00 per dozen

Cinnamon Sugar Apple 🍎 Cider Doughnuts:
A cake doughnut flavored with apple cider and rolled in cinnamon sugar
$10.00 for 1/2 dozen and $20.00 per dozen

Cinnamon Coffee Fudge:
Rich and chocolatey with notes of cinnamon and coffee, goes great with Pumpkin Spice Lattes
$10.00 for 1/2lb and $20.00 per 1lb

🍁Baker’s Fall Assortment Box🍁 $40.00
6 cupcakes (2 of each flavor)
1 dozen assorted cookies (3 of each flavor)
2 cookie sandwiches
4 doughnuts
1/4lb of fudge

**Preorders are due by Tuesday October 1st, and will be ready for pickup/local delivery on Thursday, October 3rd. **
As always, DM us, comment below, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to order your fall goodies today!

It’s officially Fall, so you know what that means…Fall 🍁🍂 Bakes:
Caramel Apple 🍏 Cookie Sandwiches:
Two large chewy apple oat cookies with a brown sugar buttercream and salted caramel drizzle sandwiched in the middle

$15.00 for a 1/2 dozen and $25.00 for a dozen

Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes 🧁:
Need we say more? Moist, fluffy pumpkin spice cake topped with cream cheese frosting or vanilla buttercream and topped with freshly grated nutmeg

$15.00 for a 1/2 dozen and $25.00 for a dozen.

Apple Pie Cupcakes 🧁:
Brown sugar butter cake with apple pie filling topped with a cinnamon cream cheese frosting.

$15.00 for a 1/2 dozen and $25.00 for a
dozen

S’mores Cupcakes:
Crushed graham cracker base, chocolate cake, topped with a graham cracker cream cheese frosting and all the s’mores fixings

$15.00 for 1/2 dozen and $25.00 for a dozen

White Chocolate Chip Pumpkin Snickerdoodles(Egg Free):
$15.00 per dozen

Molasses Cookies:
$15.00 per dozen

Apple Butter Cookies:
A moist Apple flavored brown sugar cookie, slightly chewy and rolled in sugar
$15.00 per dozen

Butterbeer Cookies:
Just like the Harry Potter beverage of choice, these have a great flavor and are a fall classic
$15.00 per dozen

Cinnamon Sugar Apple 🍎 Cider Doughnuts:
A cake doughnut flavored with apple cider and rolled in cinnamon sugar
$10.00 for 1/2 dozen and $20.00 per dozen

Cinnamon Coffee Fudge:
Rich and chocolatey with notes of cinnamon and coffee, goes great with Pumpkin Spice Lattes
$10.00 for 1/2lb and $20.00 per 1lb

🍁Baker’s Fall Assortment Box🍁 $40.00
6 cupcakes (2 of each flavor)
1 dozen assorted cookies (3 of each flavor)
2 cookie sandwiches
4 doughnuts
1/4lb of fudge

**Preorders are due by Tuesday October 1st, and will be ready for pickup/local delivery on Thursday, October 3rd. **
As always, DM us, comment below, email us at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to order your fall goodies today!

One of the celebration cakes 🎂 we put together this past week for one of our biggest supporters! A circus 🎪 themed 2nd birthday party so we had to do a big top inspired cake (2 layer vanilla cake with vanilla and raspberry buttercream)!
Happy Birthday 🎉🎈 🧁Aurelia!

One of the celebration cakes 🎂 we put together this past week for one of our biggest supporters! A circus 🎪 themed 2nd birthday party so we had to do a big top inspired cake (2 layer vanilla cake with vanilla and raspberry buttercream)!
Happy Birthday 🎉🎈 🧁Aurelia!

Congratulations to Nancy and Andrew on their wedding this past weekend! Thanks so much for allowing us to make your day just that little bit sweeter with such a unique dessert bar. It was a great day and we wish you many years of happiness and prosperity! @burntmillcountrysidebarn

Congratulations to Nancy and Andrew on their wedding this past weekend! Thanks so much for allowing us to make your day just that little bit sweeter with such a unique dessert bar. It was a great day and we wish you many years of happiness and prosperity! @burntmillcountrysidebarn

Congratulations to Nancy and Andrew on their wedding this past weekend! Thank you for choosing us to create a one of a kind dessert bar for your special day, making it just a little bit sweeter.

Congratulations to Nancy and Andrew on their wedding this past weekend! Thank you for choosing us to create a one of a kind dessert bar for your special day, making it just a little bit sweeter.

This weekend is full of family, friends, and celebration! A patriotic American 🇺🇸 cupcake cake to help mark the send off of a good neighbor’s upcoming deployment. Butterfly 🦋 themed bridal shower cookies to celebrate an upcoming wedding 💒! Thanks so much for allowing Priority Baking Company to help make your celebrations a little bit sweeter.

This weekend is full of family, friends, and celebration! A patriotic American 🇺🇸 cupcake cake to help mark the send off of a good neighbor’s upcoming deployment. Butterfly 🦋 themed bridal shower cookies to celebrate an upcoming wedding 💒! Thanks so much for allowing Priority Baking Company to help make your celebrations a little bit sweeter.

So much fun putting together another catering order for this week: cookies 🍪! Featuring our peach 🍑 cookie bars and new lemon 🍋 blackberry cookies!

So much fun putting together another catering order for this week: cookies 🍪! Featuring our peach 🍑 cookie bars and new lemon 🍋 blackberry cookies!

Today’s the last day to get your orders in for fresh picked strawberry 🍓 goodies including strawberry pie, strawberry and cream muffins, and two types of strawberry cupcakes 🧁. As always, comment below ⬇️, DM us, email at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order.

Today’s the last day to get your orders in for fresh picked strawberry 🍓 goodies including strawberry pie, strawberry and cream muffins, and two types of strawberry cupcakes 🧁. As always, comment below ⬇️, DM us, email at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to place your order.

Today is the last day to get your orders in for fresh picked strawberry 🍓 goodies including strawberry pie, strawberry and cream muffins, and two types of strawberry cupcakes 🧁. As always, comment below ⬇️, DM us, email at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to order yours today. All orders ready by this Friday, June 7th!

Today is the last day to get your orders in for fresh picked strawberry 🍓 goodies including strawberry pie, strawberry and cream muffins, and two types of strawberry cupcakes 🧁. As always, comment below ⬇️, DM us, email at prioritybakingcompany@gmail.com, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to order yours today. All orders ready by this Friday, June 7th!

Mexican Chili 🌶️ Chocolate Cupcakes 🤤

A rich, chocolate cake and icing with a kick of spice at the end will certainly heat up your next event!

As always don’t hesitate to reach out by commenting below, DM us, email us, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to order yours today!

Mexican Chili 🌶️ Chocolate Cupcakes 🤤

A rich, chocolate cake and icing with a kick of spice at the end will certainly heat up your next event!

As always don’t hesitate to reach out by commenting below, DM us, email us, or call/text direct at 717-698-6716 to order yours today!

Been a busy few weeks baking lots of new and classic goodies. Here’s one of our new ones to share, Honey Lavender Latte Sugar cookies. A delicious coffee infused sugar cookie with a creamy honey lavender buttercream frosting! Super floral for all your spring celebrations 🌷

Been a busy few weeks baking lots of new and classic goodies. Here’s one of our new ones to share, Honey Lavender Latte Sugar cookies. A delicious coffee infused sugar cookie with a creamy honey lavender buttercream frosting! Super floral for all your spring celebrations 🌷

.pro-gallery-wix-wrapper {display: block !important;} .pro-gallery-wix-wrapper .gallery-item-container {opacity: 1 !important; display: block !important;}

Follow us on Instagram

@prioritybakingcompany

bottom of page